A short explanation in your own words can reveal a connection you understand and a gap you still need to resolve
By Arbab Naseebullah Kasi, Chief Executive Officer - CEO, Feel Worldwide Foundation Inc.
You can follow a demonstration from beginning to end and still feel lost when one detail changes. The instructor's steps made sense while they were on the screen. Your notes are complete. Yet when you try the task yourself, you are unsure which part of the procedure fits the new situation.
One useful place to pause is the connection between two steps. Why does this step follow from the previous one? What principle makes it appropriate? What would change if the conditions were different?
Trying to answer those questions for yourself is different from copying an explanation. It asks you to make the relationship explicit. You may discover that you understand it well. You may also discover that the sentence you thought you understood contains a word, assumption, or link you cannot yet explain.
Either discovery can be useful, provided you have a way to check and improve your answer. The aim is not to sound clever. It is to find out what your present understanding can actually do.
What self explanation means
In learning research, self-explanation involves generating connections or inferences about the material you are studying. It goes beyond repeating the words in a source. You are working out how an idea fits with what you know or why a particular action is justified.
A meta-analysis by Kiran Bisra and colleagues, published online on March 29, 2018, examined 69 effect sizes from 64 research reports on self-explanation prompts. The overall weighted effect was positive, with Hedges' g of 0.55. That is a standardized comparison across the included research, not a claim that learners became 55 percent better. The studies covered different learning tasks and instructional conditions. Bisra and colleagues' meta-analysis
The finding is encouraging, but it is not a rule that every learner should explain every line of every lesson. It gives educators and learners a reason to consider purposeful prompts, while still attending to the material, the learner's knowledge, and the available feedback.
A small study makes the activity concrete
In a study published in 1994, Michelene T. H. Chi and colleagues asked 14 eighth-grade students to explain material to themselves as they read a passage about the circulatory system. A comparison group of 10 students read the text twice without those prompts. The prompted group showed a greater improvement between the knowledge tests given before and after reading. Chi and colleagues' study
That was a small study of a particular text and group of students. It should not be treated as a direct forecast for a workplace workshop or an adult learning a software package. Its useful contribution here is to show what the activity can look like: a learner pauses within the material and tries to connect its meaning, rather than only encountering the words again.
For practical learning, the important distinction is between describing what happened and explaining why it makes sense. “The instructor divided the total” describes an action. “The instructor divided by the number of people because the question asks for an amount per person” identifies the relationship that makes the action useful.
Choose one connection worth explaining
An instruction such as “Explain everything” can be more demanding than helpful. Start with a specific connection in material you are ready to study.
For a procedure, ask why a step is needed. For a concept, ask how it differs from a nearby concept. For a worked problem, ask which feature of the problem made the chosen method appropriate. For a diagram, ask what one relationship represents, rather than simply naming every object in the picture.
You can keep the answer short. A sentence, a sketch with a note, or a quiet spoken explanation may be enough to reveal whether the connection is clear. The format should serve the thinking, not become a performance requirement of its own.
A useful starting phrase is, “This step matters because…” Another is, “This would be different if…” Neither is a magic formula. They are invitations to make a reason or condition visible.
If you cannot begin, narrow the question. You may need a definition, a simpler example, or an instructor's explanation before you can form a meaningful connection yourself. Being unable to explain something yet is information about what support you need, not a verdict on your ability.
Try a simple example without turning it into a test of confidence
Imagine a fictional learner working through a basic spreadsheet lesson. The task is to calculate the average number of registrations across three sessions. The example totals the registrations and divides by three.
The learner writes, “We divide by three because we are spreading the total equally across the three sessions to describe their average.” That is more useful than copying the formula alone. It gives a reason for the denominator.
Now the instructor presents a variation: one session's registration count is missing, not zero. The learner has to consider what is known before deciding how to proceed. The explanation of the original calculation provides a place to discuss why a missing value should not silently become an observed zero.
The learner might initially give an incomplete answer. That is where checking matters. The instructor can clarify the distinction and ask for a revised explanation, rather than praising confident language as if it were proof of understanding.
This is an illustrative teaching scenario, not a reported result from the studies. It shows how a focused explanation can make reasoning available for examination. The learning opportunity lies in the connection and the correction, not in producing a long speech.
An explanation can also protect a mistake
There is an important caution. Explaining an answer does not automatically make that answer right.
In an August 26, 2016, account of research by Bethany Rittle-Johnson and Abbey M. Loehr, Vanderbilt University described conditions in which self-explanation could reinforce learners' existing incorrect ideas. The researchers emphasized that prompts need to fit the intended learning outcome. Vanderbilt research account
That finding argues against using “Tell me why you are right” as a universal prompt. It can be more productive to ask what evidence supports an explanation, how it compares with a reliable account, or which part needs revising.
For independent study, keep the source, solution notes, or feedback available for a deliberate check. After making your explanation, compare the reasoning, not only the final answer. If your explanation contradicts the material, identify the exact point of disagreement and seek clarification rather than inventing a reason to dismiss it.
For an instructor, the practical responsibility is to provide a correction route. A room full of learners can all be actively explaining and still need help. Activity is not the same thing as accuracy.
Make room for imperfect language
People often understand more than they can express elegantly, especially when learning in an additional language or encountering unfamiliar terminology. Do not let this practice become a competition in polished speaking.
A learner can point, draw, write a brief note, or use plain words while developing the precise vocabulary. If the lesson concerns a concept rather than public speaking, assess the concept. A hesitant but correct connection deserves attention just as much as a fluent one.
Private explanations can also be useful before public discussion. Someone may be willing to identify uncertainty on a page before announcing it to a group. Give learners a way to revise without making their first attempt feel like a permanent label.
These are practical design suggestions, not separate findings established by the numerical results above. They help keep the activity focused on understanding rather than on who is quickest to produce an impressive answer.
Check whether the explanation travels
Once an explanation has been checked, try a related question with one meaningful feature changed. Does the same reasoning still apply? If not, which condition changed?
This does not need to be a trick question. Its purpose is to distinguish remembering a sequence from recognizing when that sequence makes sense. A learner who can explain the original example but cannot handle any variation may need more guided practice or a clearer explanation of the underlying idea.
Avoid treating a single successful response as proof of mastery. Equally, do not assume that one unsuccessful attempt means the technique is useless. Look for what the attempt reveals: a missing term, a mistaken connection, an overloaded task, or a need for another example.
The explanation is one source of information about learning. It belongs alongside practice, feedback, and opportunities to use the knowledge, not in place of them.
Keep the pause proportionate
You do not need to stop after every sentence of an instruction manual. Choose a point where understanding the reason will matter later. A brief pause at a difficult connection may be more useful than a page of explanations about things you already understand.
In a training session, an educator might select one important transition and ask learners to explain it, compare their reasoning with an accurate account, and then try a variation. In personal study, you might choose the step you are most tempted to memorize without understanding.
Keep what helps and adjust what does not. If the prompt produces only repetition, ask a more specific question. If it requires knowledge the learner does not yet have, provide that foundation. If explanations become elaborate defenses of incorrect ideas, return to evidence and correction.
Learning does not always announce its gaps. Sometimes everything feels clear until you try to explain why one step follows another. That small pause can give you something valuable: a clearer connection, or a precise question to take back to the material.
What is one step you can perform today but would still like to understand more fully?

